/
In the modern enterprise, data is generated and consumed across a distributed landscape of specialized systems. A typical organization relies on a CRM like Salesforce, an ERP like NetSuite, a support platform like Zendesk, and multiple production and analytical databases. The critical technical challenge is not just accessing this data, but ensuring it is consistent, accurate, and available in real-time across all systems that depend on it.
While data integration platforms like Fivetran, Airbyte, and Stitch have become standard for populating data warehouses for analytics, they were not engineered to solve the problem of real-time, operational data consistency. Their batch-oriented, one-way data pipelines create a fundamental gap for use cases that require live, two-way data flow between the systems that run your business.
This article provides a technical comparison of Fivetran, Airbyte, and Stitch, clarifies their intended use case, and contrasts them with the operational data synchronization paradigm, where platforms like Stacksync are purpose-built to deliver real-time, bi-directional data integrity.
Fivetran, Airbyte, and Stitch are recognized in the Extract, Load, Transform (ELT) space. Their primary function is to extract data from source applications and databases and load it into a central data warehouse like Snowflake, BigQuery, or Redshift. This one-way data movement is designed to fuel business intelligence (BI), reporting, and analytics workloads.
Fivetran is a managed, closed-source ELT service known for its reliability and ease of use. It offers a large library of pre-built, fully managed connectors that require minimal setup and maintenance. The platform's core value is abstracting away the complexity of data pipeline engineering for analytics.
Strengths: High reliability, automation, extensive connector library.
Limitations: Strictly one-way data flow (no reverse ETL), batch-based with inherent latency, and a pricing model that can become expensive at scale. Custom connector development is not an option; users must rely on Fivetran's roadmap.
Airbyte is an open-source data integration engine that offers flexibility and customization. It has a growing list of connectors, many contributed by its community. This open model makes it a choice for engineering teams that require control and the ability to build custom connectors.
Strengths: Open-source, highly customizable, large number of available connectors.
Limitations: The quality of community-built connectors can be inconsistent and many are not production-ready, shifting the maintenance burden to the user. Setup and management are more complex, and like Fivetran, it is fundamentally designed for one-way, batch synchronization.
Stitch, now part of Talend/Qlik, focuses on providing a simple, developer-friendly ELT service. It is built on the open-source Singer standard, which allows users to leverage a range of open-source connectors (taps and targets). It is often favored by smaller teams and startups for its simplicity and accessible pricing tiers.
Strengths: Simplicity, lower entry cost, and extensibility through the Singer ecosystem.
Limitations: The reliance on the Singer standard means connector quality and maintenance can vary significantly. It offers limited transformation capabilities and can become costly as data volume grows.
| Feature | Fivetran | Airbyte | Stitch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Primary Use Case | Managed ELT for Analytics | Open-Source ELT for Analytics | Simple ELT for Analytics |
| Sync Direction | One-Way (Source to Warehouse) | One-Way (Source to Warehouse) | One-Way (Source to Warehouse) |
| Latency | Batch (5 min - 24 hours) | Batch (Configurable, typically minutes) | Batch (Configurable, typically minutes) |
| Connector Model | Closed-Source, Managed | Open-Source, Community & Certified | Open-Source (Singer), Managed |
| Customization | Low | High | Medium (via Singer) |
| Maintenance | Low | High (for community connectors) | Medium |
| Ideal User | Data Analysts, Teams prioritizing reliability | Engineers, Teams prioritizing control | Developers, Teams prioritizing simplicity |
The core design of Fivetran, Airbyte, and Stitch serves the analytics plane of an organization well. However, it leaves a gap in the operational plane. Business operations do not run on batch schedules; they run in real-time.
When a sales representative updates an opportunity in Salesforce, that information is needed immediately in the ERP for financial forecasting and in the company's production database to unlock new features for the customer. Waiting for a batch ELT job to run is not a viable option. This is the operational data gap: the inability of traditional data pipelines to support the real-time, bi-directional data flows required to run a modern business.
Attempting to use ELT tools for operational use cases leads to significant technical problems:
Data Inconsistency: Systems of record can become out of sync, leading to conflicting information and poor customer experiences.
Manual Workarounds: Teams may be forced to manually re-enter data between systems, a process that is both inefficient and error-prone.
Brittle Architectures: Trying to force bi-directionality by setting up two opposing one-way pipelines creates complex, brittle systems with no native conflict resolution, leading to potential infinite loops and data corruption.
Blocked Innovation: Engineering teams cannot build real-time features or automated workflows that depend on live data from multiple systems.
To close the operational data gap, a different architectural approach is required—one centered on real-time, bi-directional synchronization. This is the domain where Stacksync is engineered to excel. Stacksync is an operational data integration platform designed to keep data in sync between business applications and databases.
Unlike ELT tools that move data in one direction on a schedule, Stacksync creates a live, two-way data fabric between your most critical systems.
Key differentiators include:
True Bi-Directional Sync: Stacksync provides native bi-directional synchronization with built-in conflict resolution. It tracks the state of data in both systems, helping prevent race conditions and data duplication.
Real-Time Performance: Changes are propagated in milliseconds, not minutes or hours. This is achieved through a combination of webhooks and smart API polling, ensuring operational workflows are triggered quickly.
Automated Reliability: The platform is built with advanced error handling, detailed logging, and automated retries to help guarantee data consistency and prevent silent failures.
Effortless Scalability: Stacksync is architected to handle enterprise scale, capable of synchronizing millions of records and processing high volumes of workflow executions.
| Capability | Fivetran / Airbyte / Stitch | Stacksync |
|---|---|---|
| Sync Direction | One-Way | True Bi-Directional |
| Latency | Minutes to Hours (Batch) | Milliseconds (Real-Time) |
| Primary Use Case | Analytics & Reporting | Operational Processes & Workflows |
| Conflict Resolution | Not Applicable | Built-in, Configurable |
| Workflow Automation | Limited or None | Integrated, Event-Driven |
| Data Consistency | Eventually Consistent | Real-Time Consistency |
| Target Systems | Data Warehouse Centric | App-to-App, App-to-Database |
The choice between these platforms is not about which is "better," but which is engineered for the specific technical problem you need to solve.
Choose Fivetran, Airbyte, or Stitch when:
Your goal is to centralize data from multiple sources into a data warehouse for analytics.
One-way data flow is sufficient for your needs.
Data latency of several minutes to hours is acceptable.
You are building dashboards and reports, not powering live operational workflows.
Choose Stacksync when:
You need to keep two or more operational systems (e.g., Salesforce and PostgreSQL) in real-time sync.
Your business processes depend on immediate data availability across teams and applications.
You need to eliminate manual data entry and ensure a single source of truth for customer data.
You are building data-driven product features or internal tools that require live, consistent data.
You are seeking a modern, scalable, and more cost-effective alternative to platforms like Heroku Connect or a more focused solution than generic iPaaS platforms.
Fivetran, Airbyte, and Stitch are tools that have earned their place in the modern data stack for analytics. They solve the problem of data aggregation for BI. However, they are not the correct tools for solving the problem of operational data synchronization.
For engineering and data teams tasked with ensuring data consistency across the applications that run the business, a purpose-built solution is required. Stacksync provides the real-time, bi-directional, and reliable data fabric necessary to eliminate data silos, automate critical workflows, and build on a foundation of consistent data. By choosing the right tool for the job, you empower your teams to focus on building competitive advantages.
